In 1984, the humanity of the relationship between winston and julia is a rebellion in itself. Example of the book and movie v for vendetta essay wow essays. He said the inspector was winston and i argued gordon. The first similarity between 1984 and v for vendetta is that the society is being run by totalitarian rule. I am pretty sure that the world of v for vendetta was explicitly modelled on 1984, what with the totalitarian state, endless propaganda and constant surveillance. The novel 1984 and the film v for vendetta both present a picture of a futuristic england, from the perspective of the author at the time of the writing, in which the rights of the citizens have been severely reduced and their activities are closely watched by a powerful government. The link from v for vendetta to 1984 grows substantially with each passing scene yet still differentiating itself from the classic novel at the same time big brother, with his stalin like features, is an iconic figure in george orwells 1984 as is the inner party. Both of them have very strict politic system and the governments are able to fully control their people.
In some ways, v for vendetta resembles the french revolution more than it resembles oceania in 1984. The first similarity between 1984 and v for vendetta is that the society is being run by. How is the movie v for vendetta related to the book 1984. Hi, i am working on an essay in which i must find differences between winston smith 1984 and even hammond v for vendetta. Comparing and contrasting 1984 and v for vendetta 886. In 1984, the government, more specifically the inner party, watches every move of the people and check carefully what they do while in v for vendetta the government, more specifically the norsefire party. Name 3 differences between winston smith and evey hammond.
V for vendetta can relate to 1984 in more than a couple of ways. Need help with 1984 v v for vendetta comparison discussion in teh vestibule archive started by bearz, jun 20. There are a number of parallels between v for vendetta and 1984. Main character v is a revolutionary with big plans to take down the government, who.
If you know a difference, dont comment, add it above. The humanity of the proletarian populations in 1984 and v for vendetta is ridiculed to such an extent that it affects their potential to rebel against their tyrannical governments. Dystopian comparison of 1984 and the giver free essay example. Several students have told me that the film v for vendetta is just like 1984. Animal farm by george orwell, and v for vendetta by james mcteigue. Dystopian text 1984 and v for vendetta essay example. Censorship v for vendetta audio sweeps and news alteration, 1984 thought police and the ministry of truth different ideas living on and being inspired in other people. V for vendetta is a comic book written by alan moore.
I considered films to be books lost in translation, with popcorn entertainment replacing. In v for vendetta there was also some sort of relationship between v and evey. Yes, the graphic novel series v for vendetta by alan moore is very much like the novel 1984 by george orwell. Winston smith from 1984 and evey hammond from v for vendetta are two main characters that show many similarities and differences in these two literary pieces. The lower class in 1984 does not rebel, as their humanity alone does not make them aware that there is something for which to rebel. V for vendetta 1984 comparison essay 2306 words cram. Comparison between 1984 and v for vendetta by prezi user. Animal farm and v for vendetta both shows the comparison between of how leaders use propaganda to be seen as a loyal and upstanding. The themes of dystopia, totalitarianism, oppression, rebelliondissent. The filmmakers never denied that the political context had changed between the book and the film, as moore is a british writer, while v for vendetta is an american film, and the two works came out.
Just to prove myself right, i chose to read v for vendetta to be absolutely. Analysis of v for vendetta film studies essay uk essays. V for vendetta is about a government who has a leader that controls everything from the media to what the people could eat. Need help with 1984 v v for vendetta comparison ign. When the government has this much power over the people, the people. The governing body in 1984, the party, does a better job of restraining the general population than norsefire, the ruling political party, does in v for vendetta. Since im always interested in resources that might make orwells. Each 1984 and v for vendetta have similarities like the way the themes and how the male protagonists are the one in charge of overturning the government. Today, i am standing here to compare and contrast 1984 with v for vendetta, to analyze the purpose and conventions of the dystopian texts, and to evaluate the effectiveness of these two texts in warning about the future. Its why, when he wrote v for vendetta, he decided to mold his own.
After reading the book, 1984 by george orwell, and viewing the movie v for vendetta there have been many connections made between the characters of these two pieces. The contrast between 1984 and v for vendetta for the totalitarian rule are a bit different. The first difference i noticed was the absence of clarissa sighting the actress after buying flowers for richards party. Amongst the turmoil and destruction, v emerges victorious while winston smith succumbs to the oceanian hegemony. Its a world where old things have not just sentimental value, they are a symbol of liberty the antique shop in 1984, gordons secret room in v.
The contrast between 1984 and v for vendetta to your. In the book, this is a somewhat important event for her, one she thinks back to several times. The novel 1984 and the graphic novel v for vendetta have similar views on how society is being run. Winston and evey were both tortured, having both physical and psychological wounds. Initially published, starting in 1982, in blackandwhite as an ongoing serial in the shortlived uk anthology warrior, it morphed into a tenissue limited series published by dc comics. I had my pick among several versions of 1984, and in the end i rented a film. Its a world where total surveillance is the foundation of the society. Adaptations, limitations, and imitations writing resources. The rating of v for vendetta is a 15, meaning persons under that age are exempt from viewing the film.
Get an answer for how is the movie v for vendetta related to the book 1984. It is the government that controls the lives of the people. The movie is based on a story of the 1982 novel of the same name developed by alan moore and david lloyd. Both involve repressiveoppressive governments that monitor their citizens diligently, ferreting out any voice of resistance. The brand name of items in 1984 was victory v and v in v for vendetta was striking for a victory. One way including that they are both predictions of the future. Whats the difference between v for vendetta the graphic. Both 1984, a dystopian novel written by george orwell, and the film v for vendetta portray a world besieged by poverty, warfare, and totalitarianism. As she wrote the book, what once seemed to be a utopia, rapidly. Whats the relationship between the movie v for vendetta.
Another similarity between 1984 and v for vendetta is the relationship between the protagonist and the girl. In v for vendetta you see a masked vigilante proactively fighting to destroy the totalitarian fascist government that is in charge. Both take place in a dystopian world both in london, even. If you have read 1984 and seen the film v for vendetta then please mention comparisons about the two. A novel, often published as 1984, is a dystopian novel by english. Both of these aforementioned books both drive home the relatively same points of technology dystopian futures. The norsefire regime, in v for vendetta, basically practices the same methods used in 1984 in extremely played down ways. In 1984, the proles are the only ones with any semblance of humanity in the sense of individualism left in them. V for vendetta is a story that pits anarchism against fascism. Oppressive governments and the psychological manipulation of the people are the strong themes and warning signs that these two powerful works of art, 1984 and v for vendetta, attempt to delineate. Winston is manipulated into being a victim if you read 1984 carefully, its obvious winston has been set up as a.
Evaluation of the movie v for vendetta v for vendetta movie is a 2006 political thriller movie from collaboration between the american and german worlds directed by james mcteigue. Also, they are taking place after a war had just broken out. Orwell highlights the future, telling the past and present comparison. V for vendetta vs 1984 and brave new world ok so i have just finished reading v for vendetta and i think its a very similar book to orwells 1984 and huxleys bnw. There are lots of similarity to be found between 1984 and v for vendetta. Comparing and contrasting 1984 and v for vendetta 886 words. Winston is determined to uncover the rest of the poem. In enlightenment france, a utopian naivete fed the passionate belief that if the horrible french aristocracy and the christian clergy could be destroyed, that then. Analysis of the book 1984 by george orwell and v for. Today marks the release of the wachowski brothers new film, v for vendetta. Have you ever waited for your favorite book to be turned into a movie. It uses mass surveillance to eavesdrop on its citizens through vans patrolling the streets instead of telescreens. Whats the difference between v for vendetta the graphic novel and v for vendetta the movie.
Interestingly, the similarity between these two pieces also included v. Both works are juvenalian satires against totalitarian governments, namely the. What are the differences between vendetta and 1984 answers. Since the book 1984 was written previous to v for vendetta, so maybe v for vendetta may well have based some of its ideas on this book. Based on the graphic novel by alan moore, v imagines a british empire under totalitarian rule. The irony and constant ridicule is what makes both v for vendetta and 1984 great satires. Since the book 1984 was written before v for vendetta, so perhaps v for. Both of these novels are similar in a way like the themes and how the male protagonists are the one in charge of overturning the government. Focusing on the future societies, the governments and all that stuff. Watch the similarities and differences between the two tales of big brother and dystopian societies. The movie v for vendetta, based on the comic of the same name, can be seen as an adaptation to the book 1984 by george orwell. In comparison with both novels, 1984 by george orwell and the.
The story takes place in an imagined future, the year 1984, when much of the world has fallen. Winston and julia read parts of the book, which explains more about how the party. In comparison, the lighting and colour in eveys story is more of a blueishgreyish colour, which represents. Clements poem and the fifth of november poem ambition and control. Alex and i argued in class about who resembled winston of 1984 in v for vendetta. The first similarity that i realized is the story background setting between those two.
With the help of the thought police, newspeak, telescreens, and the ministry of love, the party seeks to control. There are definite similarities between them yet they are in no way identical which makes them perfect candidates for a compare and contrast essay. What shows the movie is related to the book, specific quotes or events. V for vendetta is a british graphic novel written by alan moore and illustrated by david lloyd with additional art by tony weare.
The proles in both 1984 and v for vendetta are powerful and unchanged due to their humanity, giving them an advantage for a potential rebellion. But in v for vendetta as well as 1984, the law was enforced at night. The governments oppressive rule is criticized in respected relationships among the characters in 1984 and v for vendetta between winston and julia, and evey and v. To try and remember the similarities and differences between these two texts in order to write about them in the exam. With reference to the movie 1984 and the movie v for vendetta, this thesis is going. A comparison between v for vendetta and 1984 essay.
Both 1984 and v for vendetta have similarities like the way the themes and how the male protagonists are the one in charge of overturning the government. Compare contrast 1984 and v for vendetta lets make a list first. However v for vendetta was based on 1984 since 1984 was written before v for vendetta. And somehow when i read the book 1984 i kept relating the whole plot of the book to the comic book. As every single year passes by, our own society starts to reflect images from these books. It also employed cameras in the public to keep eye on the people. In the alan mooredavid lloyd graphic novel and subsequent james mcteigue film v for vendetta, a 1984like totalitarian government is. Similarities and differences of v for vendetta and 1984. In 1984 winston smith had a relation with one of the party member, julia.
584 586 384 645 1535 106 872 1024 1067 637 1378 183 1479 643 975 609 527 304 140 602 158 1113 1033 148 81 803 227 295 1079 199 261 587 843 697